TODD RICHMOND
Associated Press
CHICAGO (AP) — In a stunningly fast decision, a federal appeals court in Chicago reinstated Wisconsin’s voter photo identification law on Friday — just hours after three Republican-appointed judges heard arguments on reactivating the hotly debated law in time for the November election.
In a brief order, a three-judge panel of the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago said, “The State of Wisconsin may, if it wishes … enforce the photo ID requirement in this November’s elections.”
Wisconsin officials wasted no time in saying they would do just that.
“We are taking every step to fully implement the voter photo ID law for the November general election,” said Kevin Kennedy, the state’s top election official. “We are now focused on communicating with local election officials and voters, and will have more information about the details next week.”
Wisconsin’s Republican governor, Scott Walker, heralded the court’s decision as a victory for his state.
“Voter ID is a common sense reform that protects the integrity of our voting process,” he said in a statement released by his office. “Today’s ruling makes it easier to vote and harder to cheat.”
Some Democrats expressed outrage.
“This ruling will disenfranchise Wisconsin voters and lower voter turnout in this fall’s election,” Democratic state Rep. JoCasta Zamarripa, of Milwaukee, said in a statement.
She also worried the bid to implement the law less than two months before the Nov. 4 election would cause confusion among election officials and voters.
A lower court judge, U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman struck the law down as unconstitutional in April, saying it unfairly burdens poor and minority voters who may lack such identification. Republican Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen asked the 7th Circuit to overturn that ruling.
During an hourlong hearing Friday morning, the panel sounded skeptical about depictions of the law as discriminatory.
Under the 2011 measure, those arriving at polling stations must produce a government-issued ID with a photo to vote. Because of legal challenges, the requirement had not been enforced since the February 2012 primary.
Similar disputes have arisen in nearly a dozen other states, including Pennsylvania and Texas. Republicans who back such laws say they’re designed to combat voter fraud. Critics say they’re crafted to keep Democratic-leaning constituencies — such as minorities and poor people — from voting.
While reinstating the law on Friday evening, the court did not issue a full opinion, saying it would do that “in due course.”
During arguments Friday, Assistant Wisconsin Attorney General Clayton Kawski told the panel noted he had to show ID to enter the courthouse. If photo IDs are required for getting into some buildings or onto a plane, Kawski suggested, they should be required for something far more important — an election.
But an attorney for civil rights groups said there’s no proof of any notable election fraud in Wisconsin. John Ulin shot back at proponents who say the law would engender voter confidence saying, “The law achieves the opposite effect.”
In issuing an injunction against the law in April, Adelman found that 300,000 registered voters in Wisconsin didn’t have the proper ID. Adelman noted the 2010 gubernatorial race was decided by about 125,000 votes.
During arguments Friday, Judge Frank Easterbrook, a Ronald Reagan appointee, cited figures that 2.4 percent of whites in Wisconsin can’t obtain the needed ID to vote, while 4.5 percent of blacks can’t. He asked whether that 2 percent gap between whites and blacks makes the law discriminatory.
“The answer to your question is that it can and, in this case, it does,” Ulin responded.
The other two judges on the panel were Diane Sykes and John Tinder, both appointees of Republican President George W. Bush.
___
Richmond reported from Madison, Wisconsin. AP reporters Scott Bauer in Madison and Dinesh Ramde in Milwaukee also contributed.
Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
