| Toronto 0 2 1 0_4 | |
| New Jersey 0 1 2 0_3 | |
| Toronto won shootout 3-2 | |
| First Period_None. Penalties_Grabovski, Tor (hooking), 14:25. | |
| Second Period_1, Toronto, Bozak 16 (Schenn, Lombardi), 13:47. 2, Toronto, Kadri 5 (Gardiner, Hamilton), 14:56. 3, New Jersey, Josefson 1 (Ponikarovsky, Zubrus), 18:57. Penalties_Rosehill, Tor (tripping), 16:40. | |
| Third Period_4, Toronto, Steckel 8 (Crabb, Connolly), 9:25. 5, New Jersey, Parise 29 (Salvador, Clarkson), 10:57. 6, New Jersey, Henrique 16 (Greene, Larsson), 15:18. Penalties_None. | |
| Overtime_None. Penalties_None. | |
| Shootout_Toronto 3 (Bozak G, Connolly G, Kadri G), New Jersey 2 (Kovalchuk G, Parise G, Elias NG). | |
| Shots on Goal_Toronto 7-7-3-0_17. New Jersey 18-9-15-4_46. | |
| Power-play opportunities_Toronto 0 of 0 | New Jersey 0 of 2. |
| Goalies_Toronto, Reimer 14-14-4 (46 shots-43 saves). New Jersey, Brodeur 26-20-4 (17-14). | |
| A_16,022 (17,625). T_2:35. | |
| Referees_Brian Pochmara, Kelly Sutherland. Linesmen_Jean Morin, Derek Amell. |