| New Jersey 2 1 0 1_4 | |||
| Toronto 1 1 1 0_3 | |||
| First Period_1, New Jersey, Sykora 14 (Henrique, Taormina), 9:44. 2, New Jersey, Clarkson 23 (Elias, Sykora), 14:16. 3, Toronto, Connolly 9 (Franson, Crabb), 14:32. Penalties_Phaneuf, Tor (tripping), 7:35 | Clarkson, NJ, minor-major (roughing, fighting), 16:36 | Phaneuf, Tor, major (fighting), 16:36 | Kessel, Tor (tripping), 17:34. |
| Second Period_4, Toronto, MacArthur 18 (Kulemin, Grabovski), 14:43. 5, New Jersey, Ponikarovsky 11 (Zubrus, Volchenkov), 18:11. Penalties_Boulton, NJ (boarding), 2:59 | Lombardi, Tor (hooking), 7:04. | ||
| Third Period_6, Toronto, Kessel 31 (Bozak, Lupul), 19:16. Penalties_None. | |||
| Overtime_7, New Jersey, Fayne 4 (Henrique, Kovalchuk), 1:18. Penalties_None. | |||
| Shots on Goal_New Jersey 13-8-9-2_32. Toronto 9-13-10-0_32. | |||
| Power-play opportunities_New Jersey 0 of 3 | Toronto 0 of 2. | ||
| Goalies_New Jersey, Brodeur 22-13-2 (32 shots-29 saves). Toronto, Gustavsson 16-12-2 (32-28). | |||
| A_19,426 (18,819). T_2:31. | |||
| Referees_Paul Devorski, Dean Morton. Linesmen_Scott Driscoll, Mark Shewchyk. |